October 9, 2023
The new hype cycle
I agree with everything John has to say about hype and new tools in K-12 education. The only thing I’d ask readers to remember this when thinking about the personalization that John indicates AI has the potential to bring.
The Sneaky Conservativism of Ed Tech
Alfie Kohn, 2023/09/25
Often the questions we ask mask the questions we should be asking. The problem we’re solving masks the problem we should be solving. “If you learned that kids were being fed doughnuts for breakfast every day, would your first question be whether we should add rainbow sprinkles?” Such questions help preserve – and conceal – a conservative attitude toward education, argues Alfie Kohn. They don;t address what should be changed, only whether we should use rainbow sprinkles or pixie dust. “Similarly, if we’re asking how to personalize learning — a question from which ed tech companies may ultimately stand to profit — then what we’re not asking is why a curriculum has been imposed on students and standardized to the point that it has to be personalized. If the learning were personal in the first place, if it emerged from students’ own questions about the world, there would be no need to add a separate step of harm mitigation.” Image: Seattle Times.
Web: [Direct Link] [This Post]
Originally shared in OLDaily ~ Sep 25, 2023: The Sneaky Conservativism of Ed Tech
The same kinds of standards favoured by who aggressively promote K-12 online and blended learning solutions.
The new hype cycle
Can AI be both under-hyped and over-hyped?
BY JOHN WATSON
The Gartner hype cycle is a useful framing for thinking about new technologies:
Some key elements of the hype cycle:
- Expectations inflate quickly and rapidly outstrip reality; the new technology is expected to transform the world
- When people realize that expectations were inflated, the countervailing pressure creates a sense that the new technology is close to worthless
- Eventually a balance is reached, somewhere in between the two. Often this represents the integration of the technology into existing human and organizational systems and processes.
- The plateau level matters a lot. It doesn’t necessarily stay flat, but in fact usually rises over time, although often very slowly.
- This pattern, loosely applied, is evident in ed tech examples including virtual reality, augmented reality, gaming, and other areas in the past decade or so.
AI is so big, however, that I wonder if it’s creating a different type of hype cycle—or will soon—in which the peak of expectations and the trough of disillusionment are going to operate simultaneously.
The hype is obviously happening all around us (along with real breakthroughs—it’s not just hype.)
But I think we’re starting to see, or soon will, the ways in which schools are limited in what they can actually do in the near term with AI because of existing policies, employment contracts, parent expectations, student privacy issues, and so forth.
And that’s going to lead to disappointment in the apparent capabilities of online tutoring systems, personalized learning, etc. I say “apparent” capabilities because tech enthusiasts may argue that these technologies will have far better capacities than they are able to show. I’m arguing that how they appear to many users will be disappointing because of the limiting factors—and perhaps because some systems won’t even adopt useful AI technologies in the near term.
Case in point, a recent conversation with a Colorado Division of Motor Vehicles chat bot:
This was a real conversation, and although there’s no date stamp I can verify that this conversation happened two weeks ago. Even in the moment I was more amused than annoyed at how poorly the chatbot performed. And I was briefly surprised that such a poor chatbot still exists.
I expect we’re going to see the same in public education as AI outstrips systems and processes, leading to a trough of disillusionment.
But at the same time, AI is likely to demonstrate incredible potential, keeping expectations high. Unlike the classic hype cycle, these two patterns may run in parallel, with the schools/systems/education sectors that are free of limitations able to demonstrate real and valuable uses of AI, while the policy-limited schools and systems mostly feel disappointed.
I do believe that the new plateau is going to be high, and highly disruptive. Probably not soon. A friend of mine who knows tech far better than I do told me a while back that the question in tech circles is “are we similar to Internet 1989 or internet 1999?” Meaning: are we two years away from an explosion of activity and change, or twelve years away?
An answer in education may be that we’re two years away for some, and twelve years away for others.
We welcome your comments in the DLC Community Portal’s Blog Discussion Group. If you’re already a DLC user or member, you must log in before you can join or comment in the group. If you’re not yet on the DLC platform, please create a free user account or join as a DLC member to join the discussion.
Copyright © 2023 Evergreen Education Group, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email because you opted in at the DLC or DLAC website.Our mailing address is:
Evergreen Education Group
700 Main Ave Ste EDurango, CO 81301-5437
No comments yet.
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
- SEO Powered Content & PR Distribution. Get Amplified Today.
- PlatoData.Network Vertical Generative Ai. Empower Yourself. Access Here.
- PlatoAiStream. Web3 Intelligence. Knowledge Amplified. Access Here.
- PlatoESG. Carbon, CleanTech, Energy, Environment, Solar, Waste Management. Access Here.
- PlatoHealth. Biotech and Clinical Trials Intelligence. Access Here.
- Source: https://virtualschooling.wordpress.com/2023/10/09/the-new-hype-cycle/
- :has
- :is
- :not
- 1
- 100
- 110
- 12
- 1999
- 2023
- 24
- 25
- 9
- a
- Able
- About
- activity
- actually
- add
- address
- adopt
- aggressively
- ago
- AI
- All
- along
- already
- Although
- an
- and
- answer
- apparent
- appear
- applied
- ARE
- areas
- argue
- Argues
- around
- AS
- ask
- asking
- At
- attitude
- augmented
- Augmented Reality
- auto
- ave
- away
- back
- Balance
- BE
- because
- been
- before
- begin
- being
- believe
- Better
- between
- Big
- Bot
- both
- Breakfast
- briefly
- bring
- but
- by
- CAN
- capabilities
- capacities
- Category
- Center
- change
- changed
- chatbot
- circles
- classic
- Close
- CO
- Colorado
- comment
- comments
- community
- Companies
- conservative
- contracts
- Conversation
- create
- creates
- Creating
- Curriculum
- cycle
- data
- Date
- day
- decade
- demonstrate
- different
- disappointing
- disappointment
- discussion
- disruptive
- Division
- do
- Doesn’t
- don
- Dust
- ed
- ed tech
- Education
- elements
- emerged
- employment
- end
- enthusiasts
- etc
- Even
- Evergreen
- Every
- every day
- everything
- evident
- examples
- existing
- exists
- expect
- expectations
- expected
- explosion
- fact
- far
- Fed
- feedback
- feel
- First
- flat
- For
- forth
- Free
- friend
- from
- gaming
- going
- Group
- happened
- Happening
- harm
- Have
- help
- High
- highly
- How
- However
- HTTPS
- human
- Hype
- i
- ICON
- identifier
- if
- image
- imposed
- in
- Including
- incredible
- indicates
- integration
- Internet
- into
- issues
- IT
- John
- join
- jpg
- just
- keeping
- Key
- kids
- knows
- lead
- leading
- learned
- learning
- Level
- likely
- limitations
- Limited
- logo
- Lot
- mailchimp
- mailing
- Main
- many
- mask
- Masks
- Matters
- May..
- me
- meaning
- member
- Meta
- Michael
- mine
- mitigation
- moment
- more
- mostly
- Motor
- Near
- necessarily
- Need
- New
- New technologies
- no
- of
- often
- on
- online
- only
- operate
- or
- organizational
- Other
- Others
- outstrips
- over
- Parallel
- past
- Pattern
- patterns
- Peak
- People
- performed
- perhaps
- personalization
- Personalized
- Place
- platform
- plato
- Plato Data Intelligence
- PlatoData
- please
- pm
- Point
- policies
- poor
- Post
- potential
- presentation
- pressure
- privacy
- probably
- Problem
- processes
- Profit
- promote
- public
- question
- Questions
- quickly
- rapidly
- reached
- readers
- real
- Reality
- realize
- really
- receiving
- recent
- reduce
- remember
- represents
- reserved
- resource
- rights
- Rises
- Run
- same
- say
- Schools
- Sectors
- see
- sense
- separate
- shared
- should
- show
- similar
- Simple
- simultaneously
- site
- Slowly
- Sneaky
- So
- Solutions
- Solving
- some
- somewhere
- Soon
- spam
- stamp
- stand
- standards
- Starting
- stay
- Step
- Still
- Student
- Students
- such
- surprised
- syndication
- Systems
- T
- TAG
- tech
- tech companies
- Technologies
- Technology
- term
- than
- that
- The
- the world
- then
- There.
- These
- they
- thing
- think
- Thinking
- this
- time
- to
- told
- tools
- top
- toward
- Transform
- Tutoring
- two
- type
- Ultimately
- under
- unlike
- us
- use
- User
- users
- uses
- usually
- Valuable
- Vehicles
- verify
- very
- Virtual
- Virtual reality
- was
- ways
- we
- Website
- Weeks
- welcome
- were
- What
- when
- whether
- which
- while
- WHO
- why
- Wikipedia
- will
- with
- wonder
- WordPress
- world
- would
- years
- yet
- you
- Your
- zephyrnet